NO CHANGE FOR THE SO CALLED LOW CASTE
Mitra Pariyar
University of Oxford, UK
ud.pariyar@gmail.com
Arjun Thapaliya wrote an opinion piece entitled “Dalit Movement Lacking Momentum” on Kantipur daily (27 November 2008). The following is a translated extract from his key arguments:
“In the centre-stage of Nepalese politics there has been no debate on the liberation of Dalits…Although they form 20 percent of country’s population, they are widely spread out and…..are unlikely to be impacted by the rhetoric of regional autonomy…..The Maoists…..had defined Dalits as historical proletariat and stressed for their special rights to liberate them….but nothing was offered to them. The underlying reason is the failure of Dalit movement to gather steam.”
The article presented a very abject picture of the current status of Dalits and rightly attacked the rulers as well as the Dalit leaders and activists for failing to work effectively towards bringing change. His views are very accurate and powerful.
He deserves special applause for his maverick effort, as a Bahun, to publicly express his concern for the plight of Dalits. With the exception of occasional editorial comments on papers mostly in response to the reported incidents of discrimination or violence against Dalits, I have not seen many serious voices raised by any well-known non-Dalit columnists, writers, journalists, opinions makers, party activists or leaders so far. Of course, they can go on speaking for hours on the subject when they are invited as guests to the Dalit seminars and programmes, especially if the events are followed by the cocktail dinners.
The article is evidence to the fact that it is not just Dalits who want to abolish the subordination of the low caste. We can see in the American history that there were some Whites fighting together with the Blacks in their anti-racism movement, and some even wanted to shoot their racist White fellows. His article is an equivalent of AK47 pointed at the members of the high caste who wish to keep the archaic culture of caste-based suppression intact. The irony is the big chunk of high caste that wants to see the establishment of justice and equality are outside the ruling elite, and those who rule or influence the rulers do not give a damn about it.
It is very sad, as he pointed out, that the attitude of the State towards Dalits did not change, despite popular expectation, even after the former rebels (who had claimed to champion the cause of the subaltern) took leadership of the government. In fact, this government is worse than the others because Prachanda has broken the tradition by keeping his Cabinet clean from Dalits. He is busy reaching out to the members of high caste and high class close to the former royal regime. He didn’t select any Dalit while making appointments to important state bodies, including his debated selection of “incompetent” members to the National Planning Commission. Moreover, Dalit issue has vanished from the rhetoric of almost all Maoist leaders.
They could perhaps claim that they contributed to a better representation of Dalits in the Parliament. It is correct, technically. But we do not hear any noises made by these MPs in the Parliament on behalf of Dalits who continue to face humiliation and injustices in their daily lives. Thapaliya was right when he claimed that Dalits linked to the parties are so much controlled by their high caste leaders that they can not speak their minds. Sadly, Dalit’s participation in Parliament, representing all parties, appears to be purely tokenistic.
Thapalia is equally right to point his fingers at the Dalit leaders and activists and NGO-wallas. They have never been able to sort out their differences and create a significant movement for change. However, the inaction of Dalit activists in Kathmandu does not mean all Dalits are content with their current status. In fact the resentment is growing. To show the type of resentment brewing in the villages, I present below a translated piece from the lyrics of a popular folk song, Rumal Dhoko Chhu by Raju Pariyar and Krishna Pariyar:
If you can, stop breathing as well
Because the breeze has touched us
I have washed the hankie,
Don’t drink water from this rivulet
As I have touched it.
It is the untouchable, who crafted the idol
Does the priest know this?
I have washed the hankie,
Don’t drink water from this rivulet
As I have touched it.
These powerful words are not created by any activists. Despite its revolutionary message, the singers (themselves Dalits) were not attacked or threatened by anybody. The song became a hit instead. This implies perhaps that the Nepalese society as a whole is now more prepared for change. To reify this cultural mood for change, the rulers and influential people should take the lead and direct the society towards a just and egalitarian path. The plain fact is an ordinary man in my village will not stop treating me as a low caste unless the local party activists stop doing so, and the law enforcers take it as a serious offence
If anybody believes Dalits will remain silent for ever, their judgement is wrong. Humans are inherently looking for their freedom and liberty. It is wrong for the government to negotiate only with those who organise massive strikes and bring Kathmandu to a standstill, or take part in the politics of violence. People expect the State to change now because it is headed by a party that claims to have fought and sacrificed a great deal for people. The other mainstream parties have lost public faith for a while. The government should do something quite urgently to show that the notion of republic or New Nepal is meaningful to everybody, not just for the high caste and the high class.
